If you see any of my creations and would like one made or if I still have it in my stock. I'd be happy to sell it and am available for commission anytime. My Email is in the sidebar.

Friday, May 13, 2016

Pencil Comparison

I'm comparing two different companies using a Limited Runs digi not yet available in the shop but she will be there shortly.
So there are times where your pocket book dictates what you want and what you can afford to buy and I thought I'd check out a cheaper brand of pencils out there and see how they stack up to Prismacolor Pencils so I bought Niutop - Marco Raffine Brand from Amazon it was Less then 1/2 the cost of  Prisma and I was surprized at how they ended up being not bad at all.
These images where scanned in 

As you can see by my pictures above the colours are pretty close compared and I took a picture so you could see the shine that a harder lead the left side of each is just straight pencil crayon colouring
while the right side has been blended down with a gamsol and blending stump 
(Baby oil and a q-tip can work too)
You can't really see the difference when your picture is all done 
When selecting my Prismacolors I tried my best to get as close to the Nuitop as I could.
These 2 images where taken with a camera 
You can see the colours are pretty close to each other that where used and there that much difference between them so you could purchase a cheaper brand and still achieve a great look
All the colours used in these are the little dots below  

Raffine
Lead - Little Harder, Oil Based  Goes on smooth and can be built up slowly, does have a minor shine when not blended down. Colours shade well together and give you enough selection to create good shading If you press down hard the colour is very bold.
With a light hand you can create a very super soft image (has 3 really good light skin tones) I used 6 different colours to colour in the face using browns and pinks for extra shading.
These Pencils feel similar to Derwent Studio with how hard they are.

Pro - Pencils are labeled 1-72 for those who like to keep them in order. Come pre-sharped and I had no broken leads when I got them in the post. I did have to sharpen 2 seeing I'm a klutz and broke two but they sharpened well with no breakage, Harder lead makes them harder to break
Set comes with one silver and gold pencil to.
Great set for those on a budget, and like to have a good variety of colours to play with
Con - Come in a card board box that doesn't have boards to pull out and display will need a holder to see them all easy. Not sold individually

Prismacolour
Lead -  Soft , Goes on smooth if you press a little harder you will get a deep colour instantly,
thicker lead. Colours blend over top of each other easily and can be a little harder to keep it a light touch I did have to use an eraser to lighten up a few little spots I tried to stay light but that doesn't always work
72 set does have 2 light skin tones, and light pinks and browns to add shading

Pro- Has a really HUGE selection of colours up to 150 colours.  Can be bought, individually and in small to large sets. Vibrant colours to play with along Neon colours and Metallic too. Large sets have display layers so you can have all your colours out and see them all at one time and come in handy storage boxes the flip open or have a metal case that opens up. Also has a watercolour line.

Con - Don't drop these too much as the lead have a terrible time and will break. You will have to practice more going over with a light hand to get a soft look. These where roughly 2 1/2 times more expensive



I hope you enjoyed this
Let me know what you think or have any questions
I'd be happy to answer
hugs Nikki 

6 comments:

  1. That's a good comparison Nikki. I have lots of Prismacolours now, so will keep to them for the moment. I'm getting used to the waxiness of the P's. I guess it all depends on the feel, and effect you want.
    Cheers
    Judy

    ReplyDelete
  2. Ive been meaning to try the gamsol thing - have all these coloured pencils Id like to play with :)

    Thank you for the lesson :)

    ReplyDelete
  3. Hi Nikki. I like how you show the similarities in color. The pro and cons are very informative. I wondered how you color so beautifully and would like to know about the blending tool you use.

    Hugs
    Kay

    ReplyDelete
  4. Great comparison, Nikki! I've seen Gamsol, but didn't know what it was used for. I've tried blending with baby oil once, but didn't get very good results. Your blending looks awesome! Must try Gamsol once!

    ReplyDelete
  5. What a great test you have performed. Thanks for going to all that trouble to let us know - mind you I have a huge box of Prisma pencils so don't think I will be buying any more in my lifetime.
    Shame not more people have commented - you have worked hard and so well on this post. I really appreciate it Nikki.
    Hugs, Neet

    ReplyDelete

Thanks for taking the time to comment I just love to read them. Also I have some stash for sale Here From Spellbinders to stamps and More check it out and enjoy the savings :)
hugs Nikki
Check out Visit Limited Runs Stamps
Digital Stamps for those on a budget